Scott,
I am not calling you names, what I am doing is comparing what you have said publicly with what the emails, live demos, and published correspondence actually show. That distinction matters, to me at least because you are talking about my product, where I work daily for my customers...
Your first refund request documented about 15 minutes of review across 2 of the 45 templates, with a handful of typos and demo-page link paths flagged. I fixed every item you listed the same day and pushed the updates to GitHub. That's on the record... Your review then stated 15 out of 45 templates were broken. Now you are saying you spent 8 to 10 hours reviewing by hand and found installation issues, rendering issues, and broken elements in 13 additional templates. That timeline does not hold up.
The themes are live on Lexington with full previews, in fact, anyone can see exactly how they look and behave in one click. The code you downloaded is the same code on those previews...they are pushed directly from GitHub and deployed to Cloudflare. If there were rendering issues, broken layouts, or install failures, they would show up there. They do not.
The follow-up emails arrived minutes apart, sometimes fewer than 10 minutes between messages, repeating the same vague language without theme names, steps to reproduce, or install logs. That pattern is not consistent with 8 to 10 hours of careful manual testing. The timestamps are there for anyone to check.
On the refund policy: "not as described" means the product is materially different from the listing and live previews, or that it does not function as intended. Minor placeholder copy and system-pages links are not turning a template broken, mostly because you are supposed to use your own copy.
Regarding the PDF, please open and scroll completely the document before making claims about it. Your screenshots and your written breakdown are included. Nothing was removed. Some Gmail export formatting can make text and images appear truncated, but your complaints are there in full: https://lexingtonthemes.com/documents/refund-correspondence
I am also not asking you to admit anything about how the messages were written. I am pointing at the timeline and the content of what was sent. Those things can be verified independently... you have mailguard. pro email...
If you want to post a detailed breakdown, I welcome it. Include anything you want.... Vague terms like "broken elements" or "rendering issues" are not enough when the live preview for that same theme shows it working correctly...
Out of nearly 9,000 customers, this is the only claim of this kind. I am not going to keep going back and forth in a comment thread. If you believe you are entitled to a chargeback, that is between you and your bank. But saying the entire library as essentially unusable, after documenting a small set of minor issues that were resolved the same day, is not accurate, and it is not fair to people visiting this page trying to make an honest decision.
I hope we can leave it here, I'll do what I need to do to protect the product and the people using it...